SLO doesn’t need another theater — or a parking garage to support it | Opinion

Why would anyone even consider giving away/trading valuable city property and taking on another $50 million in bonded indebtedness to meet alleged future parking needs that the city’s own consultants see no need for?

This is the San Luis Obispo City Council’s logic: We don’t have the money now but it will cost more in the future, so let’s go into more debt now to build a parking structure while interest rates are at their highest peak in 40 years, to build it and save some money in the future when we may need it!

The city has been technically insolvent for years, owing over $160 million to CalPERS for employees’ retirements and millions more in outstanding bonds. The last thing the city needs to do is take on more debt for any reason.

Perhaps the council members have not been downtown recently to see all the vacant retail spaces, many of which have been sitting empty for years now. Wouldn’t it be more prudent to find ways to get those spaces occupied and generating sales tax revenue?

The Little Theater claims it will draw 50,000 people downtown every year. With 206 seats, this means they plan to have 246 sold-out performances every year, or five sold-out performances every week. Is this realistic? Will theater patrons really park in a parking structure by the theater, walk around past the homeless to a restaurant, eat out, then walk back in the dark to go to the play? If they are going to the performance and then going home, they are not benefitting downtown businesses.

I chaired the Promotional Coordinating Committee In the 1980s, when building a performing arts center was originally proposed. The reasons the PAC was ultimately put at Cal Poly and not downtown are still valid reasons today: The building would not be in use most of the time, the city would bear the brunt of maintenance and it would eat up a large section of potentially more valuable (read: revenue-generating) space.

Part of the funding agreement for the PAC was that local organizations would have the opportunity to use the PAC. If this is not happening frequently enough, that agreement should be revisited. The parking is right there, and Cal Poly built the parking structure — not the SLO taxpayers.

Lastly, many new venues have come on board the 1990s: the PAC, the Clark Center in Arroyo Grande and numerous wineries that cater to local performers. This project has outlived its time and should be shelved along with the cassette tapes and landlines that were in use when it was first conceived.

Leslie Hall is president of the San Luis Obispo Property and Business Owners Association.

This story was originally published March 14, 2023 at 4:07 PM.