San Luis Obispo Tribune Logo

Souter: A low-profile justice who frequently dissents | San Luis Obispo Tribune

×
  • E-edition
  • Home
    • Customer Service
    • Contact Us
    • Mobile & Apps
    • Submit an Event
    • Buy Photos
    • News in Education
    • FAQ
    • Activate Digital Subscription
    • Manage Account
    • Newsletters

    • News
    • Local
    • Crime
    • Education
    • Environment
    • Investigations
    • California
    • California Weed
    • Nation & World
    • Lottery
    • Weather
    • Weird News
    • Submit a News Tip
    • Columns
    • Photos from the Vault
    • Weather Watch
    • Joetopia
    • That's SLO Weird
    • Sports
    • Outdoors
    • High School
    • Cal Poly
    • MLB
    • MLB Scores & Stats
    • NBA
    • NBA Scores & Stats
    • NFL
    • NFL Scores & Stats
    • Politics
    • The California Influencer Series
  • Business
    • Living
    • Food & Drink
    • Wine & Beer
    • Home & Garden
    • Travel
    • Columns
    • Linda Lewis Griffith
    • Pet Tales
    • Entertainment
    • Arts & Culture
    • Comics
    • Puzzles & Games
    • Horoscopes
    • Restaurants
    • Events Calendar
    • Movies
    • Music
    • TV
    • Opinion
    • Editorials
    • Viewpoints
    • Influencers Opinion
    • Editorial Cartoons
    • Letters to the Editor
    • Submit a Letter
    • Columnists
    • Tom Fulks
    • Andrea Seastrand
  • Obituaries
  • The Cambrian

  • Contests
  • Today's Circulars
  • Classifieds
  • Jobs
  • Moonlighting
  • Cars
    • Homes
    • Real Estate Weekly
  • Place An Ad

  • About Us
  • Work For Us
  • Mobile & Apps

News

Souter: A low-profile justice who frequently dissents

Michael Doyle - McClatchy Newspapers

    ORDER REPRINT →

May 01, 2009 01:49 PM

WASHINGTON — Supreme Court Justice David Souter is a private public man with a paradoxical track record.

A Republican president, George H.W. Bush, appointed him, but conservatives came to loathe him. He wrote 156 majority opinions and 123 dissents, but few scream out for attention. He's a perfect gentleman during oral argument, but a dog with a bone when he's demanding answers.

"He can sink his teeth into something and not let someone off the hook," said Tom Goldstein, a Washington attorney who's argued multiple cases before the Supreme Court. "He can be incredibly focused."

The 69-year-old Souter, who lives modestly and alone, has had the lowest profile of any current justice. Unlike several others, he doesn't become a globetrotting teacher during the summers, and he's never hidden his discomfort with Washington.

SIGN UP

Sign Up and Save

Get six months of free digital access to The Tribune

SUBSCRIBE WITH GOOGLE

#ReadLocal

"When the term of court starts, I undergo a sort of annual intellectual lobotomy and it lasts until the following summer, when I sort of cram what I can into the summertime," Souter told an audience at the American Academy of Arts and Sciences in March.

Judicially, too, Souter has been modest. He doesn't adopt the professorial tone of Justice Stephen Breyer, the man-in-the-middle role of Justice Anthony Kennedy or the confrontational brilliance of Justice Antonin Scalia. He admires his fellow New Englander Oliver Wendell Holmes Jr., who was on the court from 1902 to 1932 and about whom he wrote his Harvard College thesis, but he never cultivated Holmes' taste for the memorable aphorism.

"He's a very honest judge, who candidly looks at every case, and comes to a conclusion irrespective of the president who appointed him," said Goodwin Liu, a former Supreme Court clerk who now teaches at the University of California's Berkeley Law School.

In 1992, for instance, conservatives were watching closely as the Supreme Court considered the case called Planned Parenthood v. Casey. Some saw the challenge to Pennsylvania's "informed consent" law as an opportunity to overturn the Roe v. Wade decision that enshrined abortion rights.

Souter, however, joined justices Sandra Day O'Connor and Anthony Kennedy in a so-called plurality opinion that began "liberty finds no refuge in a jurisprudence of doubt," and stressed that the "essential holding" of Roe v. Wade was being upheld. In an unusual twist, the ruling opinion was attributed to all three justices instead of one chief author.

"That was a testament to his ability to find a middle ground," Liu said.

The Casey decision and others like it also testified to the ability of a lifetime-tenured Supreme Court justice to surprise political patrons and opponents alike. In 1990, the group then called the National Abortion Rights Action League declared Souter's nomination part of a "frighteningly successful" campaign to "deprive Americans of their fundamental rights."

By Friday, when reports of Souter's impending retirement began spreading widely, many were singing a different tune.

"He was eminently fair, exceptionally bright and thoughtful, and he refused to carry out a political agenda on the bench," said Nan Aron, the executive director of the liberal advocacy group Alliance for Justice, "and that was a fact that surprised many in the Republican Party."

Put another way, Ed Phelan of the conservative Ethics and Public Policy Center characterized Souter on Friday as "a terrible justice," and Republicans repeatedly have cast him as an ideological turncoat.

Souter defies quick-and-easy stereotyping. A former New Hampshire attorney general, he's often sided with law enforcement on search-and-seizure issues, Aron said. On key business disputes, too, he's periodically sided with the pro-business side.

In June, for instance, Souter wrote the majority opinion in a 5-3 decision that dramatically cut the fine that Exxon-Mobil had to pay for the disastrous 1989 Exxon Valdez oil spill in Alaska. The important decision reduced Exxon's liability from $2.5 billion to about $500 million, and will help curtail future corporate fines as well.

"It is really only in the context of the current court that he's considered a liberal," noted Stanford Law School Professor Pamela Karlan. "I think he's really a classic example of what we've recently seen to be a disappearing species, the Northeast Republican moderate."

In a court dominated by other Republican nominees, Souter often ends up on losing side. Of 48 Supreme Court decisions issued since the current term began, Souter has dissented 15 times. By contrast, Kennedy has dissented only three times so far this term.

Only Justice John Paul Stevens has dissented more frequently than Souter has during this term, records compiled by Scotusblog show.

On Tuesday, for instance, Souter and Stevens joined in dissent on a 5-4 case in which the conservative majority ruled that federal regulators could fine broadcasters for airing a fleeting swear word.

"He'll be remembered for careful and meticulous reasoning," Karlan said, "and he'll be remembered for being in dissent a lot."

MORE FROM MCCLATCHY

Justices consider whether strip search is OK

Souter tells White House that he'll retire from Supreme Court

Supreme Court seems closely divided on felon's right to DNA test

Related stories from San Luis Obispo Tribune

news

Obama likely to get nominee he wants for Supreme Court

May 01, 2009 02:37 PM

news

Souter tells White House that he'll retire from Supreme Court

April 30, 2009 07:57 PM

HOMEPAGE

Justice Souter’s Biography

May 01, 2009 02:38 PM

HOMEPAGE

Read McClatchy's Supreme Court coverage

April 30, 2009 09:34 PM

  Comments  

Videos

Injury collision on Cuesta Grade involving SUV and semi-trailer

Want to throw confetti on this SLO hill? Littering could cost you

View More Video

Trending Stories

3 injured in major crash between minivan and big rig on the Cuesta Grade

February 20, 2019 03:26 PM

The legend returns: Willie Nelson is coming to Paso Robles

February 19, 2019 11:31 AM

SLO County is the 7th least affordable place to buy a home in the entire United States

February 19, 2019 06:47 PM

An unsettling sight: Someone strung dead coyotes along a fence near Oakdale

February 20, 2019 12:04 PM

Ex-pastor caught in underage sex sting in Arroyo Grande sentenced to state prison

February 20, 2019 01:03 PM

Read Next

World

Death toll from Pakistan flash floods, rains rises to 26

The Associated Press

    ORDER REPRINT →

February 21, 2019 02:14 AM

Torrential rains, flash floods in Pakistan leave at least 26 dead, many swept away by the waters or killed when roofs collapsed.

KEEP READING

Sign Up and Save

#ReadLocal

Get six months of free digital access to The Tribune

SUBSCRIBE WITH GOOGLE

MORE NEWS

More than 150 IS militants handed over to Iraq from Syria

World

More than 150 IS militants handed over to Iraq from Syria

February 21, 2019 01:39 AM
Pope demands bishops act now to end scourge of sex abuse

World

Pope demands bishops act now to end scourge of sex abuse

February 21, 2019 01:36 AM

National

School bus driver revived with Narcan after crash

February 21, 2019 03:29 AM
AP Photos: Looking back at historic first Trump-Kim summit

World

AP Photos: Looking back at historic first Trump-Kim summit

February 21, 2019 03:28 AM
Airlines need better info before flying over conflict zones

Business

Airlines need better info before flying over conflict zones

February 21, 2019 03:24 AM
The Latest: Abuse victims tell bishops of trauma, pain

World

The Latest: Abuse victims tell bishops of trauma, pain

February 21, 2019 03:19 AM
Take Us With You

Real-time updates and all local stories you want right in the palm of your hand.

Icon for mobile apps

San Luis Obispo Tribune App

View Newsletters

Subscriptions
  • Start a Subscription
  • Customer Service
  • eEdition
  • Vacation Hold
  • Pay Your Bill
  • Rewards
Learn More
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Newsletters
  • News in Education
  • Archives
Advertising
  • Place a Classified Ad
  • Advertise with Us
  • Local Deals
  • Public Notices
Copyright
Privacy Policy
Terms of Service


Back to Story