Judith Light Gives Everything to ‘The Terror: Devil in Silver'

Judith Light has never been afraid to go to uncomfortable places. In The Terror: Devil in Silver, the AMC+ anthology series streaming on Shudder, she plays a woman institutionalized against her will by her husband-abandoned in a psychiatric ward and left to navigate whatever horror lurks within its walls. It’s the kind of role that demands everything, and Light, characteristically, gives it.

“There’s nothing to get in life,” she told Newsweek. “There’s only what you can give.”

That philosophy has defined a career that has refused every expectation placed on it, from Who’s the Boss to prestige drama to the stage, where she once shaved her head and performed nude in the play Wit to prove to Hollywood what she was capable of. “I have experience, I have garnered wisdom through the years, I am a team player and I know what you need,” she says. At this point, no one would argue.

SUBSCRIBE TO PARTING SHOT PODCAST WITH H. ALAN SCOTT ON APPLE PODCASTS, SPOTIFY, OR WHEREVER YOU GET PODCASTS.

Editor’s Note: This conversation has been edited and condensed for publication.

My first question - and I mean this in the best possible way - there is nobody else I want to see playing someone in a psychiatric institution than you. Nobody.

I love that! [laughs] I was excited to see me in a mental institution too.

You’re at a point in your career where you’ve done everything and can do anything. When you get a script like this, with an incredible team and cast, do you go back to your soap opera days and think, I can eat this scene up?

I don’t do that. That was a great training ground for me and then I had to really wean myself away from that. You have to let those things go. My learning about acting really happened from that to Who’s the Boss, to the movies of the week, and I really learned something else when I was doing Transparent. But with this particular script, with the Devil in Silver, literally they sent it to me and I read two lines and I called the agent and I said, I’m in. I knew what this could be. And I loved Dan Stevens’ work [plays Pepper]. And then they started putting this team together. Karyn Kusama as the director, I’d known about her work. I knew Chris Cantwell’s work [writer/co-creator]. Victor LaValle [writer] is a New York Times bestselling author. I knew what the pieces would be. So I don’t think, oh, whoopee, let me chew the scenery here. That doesn’t register anymore.

For fans of yours, as soon as we see you in a trailer for a show like this, we immediately know that’s what we want from Judith. You have this ability to be everything in a scene. In a show where you have so much to work with and actors who give you so much, it’s exciting to watch you go places we know you can go - because we don’t even know where you’ll end up.

You have to know how much I appreciate that. And this gave me the opportunity to do that. The audience and the fans mean the world to me. I have the longevity that I have because of the people who watch me and who respect my work and appreciate my work. And when I go into a character, I don’t think about expanding anything. I look at what’s on the page and I bring to that what I dig for in myself. I’m always thinking about what it could be and how the audience will be responding, to understanding this human being. Years ago, after One Life to Live and Who’s the Boss, people didn’t know what I could do. And I knew that. I had a manager who said to me, they’re not gonna figure it out for themselves. That’s not their job. That’s your job to let people know the level of versatility at which you can work. So I began to go through that journey. I did a play where I had to shave my head and was bald for a year. Was naked on stage. All the things I swore I never would want to do, that I knew I had to do in order to say, please look at what else I can do.

How do you balance what could be “crazy” behavior with creating a real, human character? How does it not tip into overacting territory?

It’s very challenging. And sometimes I go too far. Sometimes I do too much. And I get that. I rely on the director. I say to the director, here are my traps. Here are the things that I need you to watch and catch me on. Karyn Kusama, when I was doing the Devil in Silver, I said, keep an eye on me, so I know where I can go that could be problematic. And Karyn would say, you can cut back here. That’s what I rely on, somebody else’s eyes. Not my own. People say, how did that feel, was the scene good? And it’s like, I don’t know. If you can tell somebody that it was good, you’re probably not really deeply into it enough. You’re not being present. You have to tell me how it read. I remember when I was doing Wit, one night I came off and I said, I got it. I did it. And my manager at the time said, no, you were indulgent and you went 10 minutes over. And then another night I said, oh my god, it was just the worst performance I’ve ever given. He said, that was right on. That was the performance. So you can’t really tell if you’re judging it and watching it. That’s why I rely on somebody else’s eyes.

That speaks to your talent, your job is to let your talent take you where it needs to go and trust someone else to handle the direction and the editing.

That’s right. And what I say to a director is, I will give you a smorgasbord. I will give you two from column A, two from column B. I’m not wedded to any of these choices. You pick. Because I am a part of a piece. I am not the whole piece. I am a cog in the wheel. And if that cog is out of step with everything else, I’m not doing my job. When you have a show like Devil in Silver and you have phenomenal writing, a phenomenal showrunner like Chris Cantwell, a director like Karyn Kusama, a producer like Brooke Kennedy, Victor LaValle, and then actors like Stephen Root and Dan Stevens and CCH Pounder and Aasif Mandvi, I have to fit myself into that. And the director knows that. And the showrunner knows that. And Victor also knows how he wrote this novel. Who is she, and how does she present?

We don’t see you in this genre enough - and you’re so good at it. What appeals to you about it?

When you watch the Devil in Silver, you have to decide who the monster is, if the monster is real, or if the monster is in you. What it also brings up is the mental health of our world, of our communities. What do we do with our people who have mental challenges? What does it mean to be a woman, this character that I play, who is taken by her husband, who has trouble with her and how she is and her artistic nature, and takes her to a mental institution, a psychiatric ward, lies to her and leaves her there and never comes back for her. There are those stories out there. So what I get to do by being in this genre is talk about the adjacent ideas that come with this. What are we doing for our homeless people, because many of them have mental challenges? How are we relating to people who are outside the norm? How do we relate to the other? All of that feels essential to me. Because my work for me is my service. There’s nothing to get in life. There’s only what you can give. And so in this genre, I get to do a lot of giving.

The pivot from Who’s the Boss to TV movies of the week could have been the end of your career, especially for women in Hollywood. But you found a way to show a completely different side of yourself. What do you recall as the moment you felt things were going to be different?

I don’t know that I ever felt it. I never felt that thing like, oh, here comes the pivot. But I knew that when I took over for the brilliant Kathleen Chalfant in that play [Wit], I was terrified. I hadn’t been on stage in 22 years. That was a jumping-off place because what I had to do was face every fear I ever had about facing the critics in New York, being bald for almost a year, being naked on stage. It couldn’t have been just like, you know, do a nice little play off-Broadway. It was like, no, she’s gonna do this. And she’s going to be naked and she’s gotta be bald and she’s gotta go on tour. Encapsulated in that was the facing of fears and really knowing that I could do more and wanting other people to know that. And I don’t think it works to say, oh, Hollywood is like this, or women in Hollywood are like this. Look at who’s working now, Kathy Bates, Michelle Pfeiffer. Michelle Pfeiffer is redefining what the grandmother is. If you don’t lock into somebody else’s idea of what it’s gotta be, it’s like, that’s somebody else’s opinion. I have experience, I have garnered wisdom through the years, I am a team player and I know what you need. I don’t hold with what other people say about the way things are. It hasn’t served me in my career. But if you look at who’s working now, there’s a bunch of us that are mature women and people want to see it. Because they know that they want to see themselves.

There’s also a nostalgia factor. For elder Millennials like me who grew up watching you, seeing you in a project like Transparent or Devil in Silver immediately brings me back, and then delivers something completely new. You’re able to use that familiarity to open a door and then show me something I wasn’t expecting.

What a thought. I think that’s why people love LeVar Burton. You remind me of how I felt. And I always said, particularly about Transparent, you don’t watch Transparent. You feel Transparent. There is a level of feeling that has to come across through that camera out to you that makes you feel something. And unless I’m doing that, I’m not doing my work. People used to say to us when we were doing Transparent, this is so helpful to me with my cousin who’s trans or my family member. Even if it wasn’t an issue about a trans issue or an LGBTQ issue, it was that it was a family issue. And so those thoughts, without becoming didactic, become universal. And unless we’re reaching each other and including you as family, I just don’t think we’re doing our job.

2026 NEWSWEEK DIGITAL LLC.

This story was originally published May 22, 2026 at 11:26 AM.