I believe Cal Polys entrance into the Big Sky Conference misbrands Cal Poly academically, misidentifies it regionally, creates few (if any) rivalries or fan excitement and does not enhance the prestige of the university.
Cal Poly has evolved under the leadership of President Warren Baker into an elite, highly-ranked institution. The Big Sky Conference is made up of schools that I believe are of the highest quality.
However, their ranking by U.S. News and World Report, which has become widely accepted, certainly differs with my assessment.
Among national univer-sities, Montana State University is ranked 183 and the University of Montana is ranked 191. The University of Northern Colorado, Portland State University and Idaho State University are all ranked in the second tier of national universities, meaning that according to U.S. News and World Report, they are ranked between 198 and 260.
Among western regional universities, Eastern Washington and Weber State are tied at 56 and Sacramento State is ranked at 62. Few conferences in the nation have a lower academic rating than the Big Sky Conference.
Clearly, Cal Polys academic reputation is not enhanced by membership in the conference.
When most people think of Big Sky, they think of Montana, which has Big Sky Country on its license plate, but I never heard of anyone refer to the beautiful Central Coast of California as Big Sky Country. Why Cal Poly wants to be labeled as part of Big Sky Country is beyond me.
It is hard to believe that football fans in San Luis Obispo will be excited by many of the Big Sky Conference matchups. Many of the schools in the conference, I expect, are not known to local fans. I suspect few, if any, fans can identify the city and state in which Weber State is located and few can identify the cities in which Northern Colorado, Idaho State and Eastern Washington are located.
Games against Montana and Montana State may cause excitement and a rivalry may be established. However, many people believe that both of these institutions will leave the Big Sky Conference and join the Western Athletic Conference or another bowl championship series conference. Cal Poly versus UC Davis will create excitement and a rivalry, but this could have been accomplished by both teams joining a bowl championship series conference.
Reputations of some universities are rising while others are waning. President Baker, who doesnt receive enough credit in my estimation, is responsible, in large part, for increasing the value of a Cal Poly degree.
There are many elements that go into the matrix of increasing a colleges value. Football, for many institutions, has been one of the avenues to accomplish this.
Most say Boise States academic reputation has increased, in large part, to its success on the gridiron. University of Southern California is ranked as one of the top 25 universities in the nation, aided by a successful football program.
When Northwestern went to the Rose Bowl, the next year their applications increased substantially, positioning Northwestern to be even more selective in the selection of students. Cal Poly, in my opinion, gets no pluses for being in the Big Sky Conference and likely its reputation as an academically-demanding institution will be diminished by being a member.
In my judgment, Cal Poly should have made an all out effort to join a BCS conference. I know that joining a BCS conference would require expanding the existing stadium and offering additional scholarships. These costs would have to be covered by alumni contributions.
Estimates have ranged between $9 million and $30 million to upgrade the stadium and there would be the ongoing cost of funding additional scholarships. I believe it would have been appropriate to go to the alumni, test their resolve to be in a BCS conference and set an immediate goal of raising the money.
I believe that the money could have been raised. Cal Poly has very rich alumni, many famous alumnus and thousands of alumni who would like to see Cal Poly play big time football.
I further realize that additional problems regarding Cal Polys desire to participate in the Big West Conference in sports other than football would have to be resolved. Perhaps it could have been resolved by a potential BCS Conference in the same way the Big Sky Conference resolved the issue by simply waiving requirements that Cal Poly and UC Davis play all conference sports in the conference. According to many, Cal Poly is a sleeping giant whose membership would be welcome by many BCS conferences. What disturbs me most is the administration didnt make a concerted effort to try to overcome the necessary hurdles to become a member of a BCS conference. Cal Poly has a rich football history and its students, alumni and friends deserved a better effort.
I graduated from Cal Poly in 1965. While attending, I worked as an usher at football games and saw the greats of this era play.
I served as both a California State Assemblyman and State Senator as well as on a committee appointed by President Baker that was charged with making recommendations concerning the evolution of Cal Polys football program.
I love Cal Poly and I believe that membership in a BCS conference would have been in the best interests of this great and distinguished university.
Bob Wilson is a retired California senator who currently lives in Florida.